Friday, February 25, 2011

Journal - 2/25/11

This week in our Lit Circle, my group and I discussed characters, namely Heathcliff and Lockwood, and the presence of destruction, pain, and conflict within the book, Wuthering Heights, by Emily Bronte. On Wednesday, we came to the conclusion that though Heathcliff looked like a well mannered gentleman, inside he was cynical, morose, indifferent, and suspecting. This is shown in the book when Lockwood visits Wuthering Heights for the first time, and gets attacked by Heathcliff’s dogs. Heathcliff seemed to view the situation as mere amusement, and when Lockwood complained about the attack, Heathcliff implied that Lockwood was trying to steal something from him. It gives readers a hint of Heathcliff’s past: he might’ve had many things taken away from him, causing him to become weary and fearful that someone will walk into his life and leave with something precious. On the other hand, Lockwood’s most apparent features are his curiosity and the fact that he’s opinionated. Even though Heathcliff gave obvious hints of his aversion to company, Lockwood kept visiting anyways, hoping to learn more about his landlord. Only after talking to Heathcliff a few times, Lockwood formed a judgment on his character and blamed it on possibly “underbred pride.” On Friday, we looked at paragraph 5 of page 70 in the book because it demonstrated destruction, pain, and conflict. In that paragraph, destruction is the regression of character; pain is emotional pain as opposed to physical pain, and the conflict is one that is internal. We looked mainly at how Catherine’s change of identity first inflicted great emotional pain on Heathcliff. It was as if he lost his only friend and the only thing that brought him joy. This led him to having to make a decision between being true to himself or change to conform with Catherine’s new identity. When he tried to change, he tried with no avail because Hindley was so keen on keeping him away from Catherine. This led to his “mental deterioration,” exaggerating his previously ill, reserved disposition. Because of the former Mr. Earnshaw, Heathcliff possessed an extreme sense of pride. He knew it was impossible for him to succeed in his environment, so he purposely “sank beneath his former level” to make a statement that he didn’t care and he wasn’t trying. This relates to many people in the world today since there are so many people who develop self destructive behavior just because they believe they have no chance at success. It seems like we forget that there are plenty of people out there who were worse off than ourselves, yet they’ve attained success because they never gave up. Those are people we need to look up to and aspire to be.

In the two discussions we’ve had so far, I think our group is off to a good start. We all participate and offer insight on the subject at hand, and we often help build on others’ ideas. We present our opinions with evidence from the story, and we try to go deeper than the surface of the story. One thing we can improve on is asking more questions. I think if we ask more questions, it’ll give us opportunities to discover even more from the story.

No comments:

Post a Comment