This Tuesday, my group’s discussion didn’t really have a structure as to exactly which component of Wuthering Heights, by Emily Bronte, we were discussing. We just started talking about what happened in chapters eight to twelve while bringing up our thoughts and questions on the events of those chapters as well as the rest of the book. I remember my group being mainly concerned with the relationship between Isabella and Heathcliff and the true reasons behind Heathcliff’s advances towards Isabella. Catherine had married Edgar because of her concern with image and class, and Heathcliff had run off because he heard Catherine say, “It would degrade me to marry Heathcliff now; so he shall never know how I love him.” (p.82) A few years later, he unexpectedly comes back to Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange appearing as if he were a completely different person. “He had grown a tall, athletic, well formed man.” (p.96) His countenance “looked intelligent, and retained no marks of former degradation… His manner was even dignified.” (p.96) Though his appearance was transformed, you could say his insides were as rotten as ever: just as deceitful, twisted, and manipulative if not even more so. After heathcliff’s arrival, Hindley had been “borrowing money on his land, and does nothing but play and drink.” (p.104) Heathcliff was initially planning on getting revenge on Hindley through Hareton, Hindley’s son. He had been teaching him to “swear at Daddy” and telling him to do as he will. (p.110) Unfortunately, Heathcliff learned of Isabella’s love for him, and told Catherine, “thank you for telling me your sister-in-law’s secret: I swear I’ll make the most of it.” (p.112) Isabella ended up running off with Heathcliff and marrying him against Edgar’s will. We inferred that Heathcliff was using Isabella to anger Edgar, but we’re unsure about his other motives. I proposed the theory that in the big picture, Heathcliff had a goal of being with Catherine: he had never really given up on the idea. If married Isabella, he would gain a higher social status, and if Edgar were to die, all of Edgar’s assets would go to Isabella and him if Edgar didn’t have another heir. With that, Heathcliff would have all the material objects necessary to win Catherine back, and all he had left to do was turn Catherine against her husband and everyone around her, which for Heathcliff, shouldn’t even be considered an obstacle. It's inhuman how much enjoyment Heathcliff gets from the destruction of those around him; his past has stripped him of any compassion he once had. He feels with his mind instead of his heart, and he doesn't live; he exists to devastate.
In our discussion today, we focused on the subjects of pain, power, and destruction, pointing out how the destruction in the story began with the power Heathcliff acquired though Mr. Earnshaw: Hindley turned bitter with jealously of his father’s love for Heathcliff. Heathcliff had the ability to gain anything his heart desired, even at the expense of Hindley or even Catherine, because Mr. Earnshaw held him up on a pedestal. In Mr. Earnshaw’s eyes, Heathcliff was an angel and whenever there was conflict, he was the victim. When Mr. Earnshaw passed, all the power was handed over to Hindley, and he invested all that power in the destruction of Heathcliff. "He drove him from their company to the servants, deprived him of the instructions of the curate, and insisted that he should labour out of doors instead." (p.49) At first, Hindley seeked revenge on Heathcliff and Catherine by treating them as servants, but as time went by, it became apparent that Heathcliff would be happy as long as he had Catherine. Hindley then made a plan to transform Catherine into an elegant, neat, mannered young lady, so Heathcliff would no longer have anything in common with her. "Instead of a wild, hatless little savage jumping into the house... there lighted from a handsome brown pony a very dignified person, with brown ringlets falling from the cover of a feathered beaver." (p.55) The events of the story provide an answer to the question of whether or not pain promotes growth: it depends on the person. For example, Hindley’s pain only caused his degradation, yet though Heathcliff’s pain caused his degeneration at first, it ultimately led to his metamorphosis. The disparity between these two characters is that one’s emotional endurance was hardened while the other’s was not. Sometimes a single factor can make all the difference; it all really comes down to the most prevailing characteristics of the character in question.
The conflict of power between Heathcliff and Hindley runs parallel to that of the Rwandan genocide. Mr. Earnshaw is equivalent to the Belgians, Heathcliff to the Tutsis, and Hindley to the Hutus. When the Belgians colonized Rwanda, they gave all the power to the Tutsis and the Tutsis abused their power over the Hutus. When the Belgians left, the power was left to the Hutus, and the rest was history. It’s obvious that the once the powerless gained all the power, a large fraction of that power would be put towards revenge. The beginnings of conflict in Wuthering Heights and those of the Rwandan genocide are nearly identical, and that fact makes it evident that "an eye for an eye makes the world go blind" (Ghandi) When we are constantly seeking revenge, the cycle will never end. It would be best if we learn to forgive and save the world from a mass of unneeded rancor.
There’s so much to discuss in our lit circles that it seems like our time just flies by. We have no shortage of discussion, evidence, examples, or insight, but I think we need to try to fit all of our comments and ideas into the time we have. Overall, we work really well together as a group
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI love your Rwandan genocide connection, I never noticed that before. I like how your use of it reflects the truth in the reflection of the different character's darknesses among generations. You mentioned that pain effects us differently based on our characteristics, if you were to add anything maybe expand on that and explain how we develop emotional endurance, or how the characters did. Does having small doses of pain over a lifetime harden it or is it singular extreme exposures? Why did Heathcliff develop a stronger endurance than Catherine who always feels pain at the smallest of situations?
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed your journal and admire your quote usage :)
YOu folks should keep up the discussion:) Have others in your group share.
ReplyDelete