Thursday, April 14, 2011

Journal - Edited

What exactly is it that drives a person into the arms of immorality? Through our last group discussion, I have come to the conclusion that the genesis of malevolence comes not from the theoretical evil that already exists within that person, but rather from the accumulation of memories, experiences, and perspicacity that the said person has acquired throughout the course of his or her life. This is evident in the multiple connections that our group made with the plot of Wuthering Heights, by Emily Bronte.

In chapter four of Wuthering Heights, Heathcliff enters Hindley Earnshaw’s life “a dirty, ragged, black-haired child.” –p.41 His father, Mr. Earnshaw, saw Heathcliff as “a gift of God, though [he was] as dark almost as if [he] came from the devil.” –p.40 “He took to Heathcliff strangely, believing all he said, and petting him up far above Cathy.” –p.42 Hindley despised the fact that his father was putting this stranger above every other person on Wuthering Heights because in his eyes, heathcliff was just an “usurper of his father’s affections and privileges, and he grew bitter with brooding over these injuries.” –p.42 This overwhelming jealousy led to his violent, abusive behavior towards Heathcliff, dedicating his own life to destroy that of Heathcliff’s. Though his efforts did manage to put a dent in Heathcliff's life, they did much more harm to his own. I would say that Hindley's sacrifices weren't worth the satisfaction of a little vengeance.

I’ve had a similar experience to this, and though it’s not as extreme, it has the same foundation. My little sister is the youngest in our immediate family. All her life, she has been the center of attention, and at the time, when she was about 8, that was her lifestyle, if you will. That winter, our cousins came to visit us, and one of those cousins was a cute, tiny, little three year old girl named Nicole. It was no surprise that as soon as she came into the house, she stole the spotlight. A person who has lived in and enjoyed being the center of attention all her life, only to have it taken away by a clueless toddler who barely knows how to speak is bound to develop a sense of resentment. Because of the bitter emotion we know as jealousy, my sister was constantly trying to hurt Nicole, teasing her, pranking her, making her cry, but like the case of Hindley, those misdemeanors didn’t do any good for her own position. It only gave Nicole even more attention, for whenever she was in distress, the adults sought to comfort her. Like Hindley, my sister gave up more than it was worth just for a little taste of revenge. The disposition she had developed over her life had come back to haunt her.

Human lives are, in essence, like the buildings we see on the street every day. In the beginning of our lives, we lay a foundation from our experiences that will determine who we may or may not become. By a certain time, the structures of our characters are pretty much complete, and it is nearly impossible for us to change. The only features we can change are those minor characteristics that don’t leave much of an impact on our identities; the rest we can’t disturb without destroying ourselves. What’s left of a building after its foundation is destroyed? Pieces of what used to be complete.

-----------------------------------------------

Metacognative Reflection: I think our group has continued to work well during our discussions, doing everything we have been doing before. Discussions have gotten more intriguing since we started our new book, Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, as it’s a different story and the ideas and concepts within it are fresh and new.

1 comment: